Other: a place for the cider, the beer and the bottle that isn't wine
By jagduvi
Tags: cellar, registry, app
The rack doesn't care what's in the bottle
Cellarion is a wine cellar. But a wine rack is just a rack, and most of them hold a few things that aren't wine: a vintage cider somebody brought back from Normandy, a barrel-aged stout that needs a year, a bottle of calvados, the Christmas port that turned out to be a sherry. Several of you told us so, in support tickets and by adding them anyway, typed as "sparkling" because that was the nearest thing on offer.
That worked, mostly, but it was wrong in a way that bothered us. A cider labelled sparkling looked like a wine to everyone. It sat in the shared wine registry that every member searches. Our sommelier, who keeps that registry honest, found it hours later and moved it aside. And your bottle page offered it a drink window and a tasting profile that could never be right.
What changed
When you add something that isn't wine, choose Other where you would choose the type. That is the whole gesture. From that moment:
- The drink lives in your cellar only. It never enters the shared wine registry, so nobody else's search is cluttered with it, and no curator has to tidy up after it. You can still find it in your own search, and add more bottles of it the usual way.
- It carries no wine type, no grapes, no appellation. The bottle page shows an "Other" pill instead and leaves out the sections that only make sense for wine, such as the sommelier's drink window and the tasting profile. Your own notes, rating, price, rack position and drink window stay exactly as for any bottle.
- Your cellar filters and statistics gain an Other bucket, and the rack view draws these bottles in neutral grey.
If you already have a cider or a beer in your cellar typed as wine, open its bottle page and use "Not a wine? Move it to Other". When only a few members hold bottles of that record it moves at once; when many do, a curator takes a look first, because hiding a shared record from everyone is their call.
Everything our sommelier had already set aside as "not wine" over the past months now shows as Other by itself. Nothing to do on your side.
What hasn't changed
Cellarion is still about wine. The Other category is deliberately plain: no beer styles, no cask strengths, no best-before dates. If you want to record something like that, the personal data fields on a bottle are made for it, and they work on an Other bottle as they do on a Barolo.
If you connect an AI assistant to Cellarion, it can do all of this too: adding with category "other", and moving a record to Other.
Thank you to the members who asked, and who kept adding their ciders in the meantime. That is how we knew the rack doesn't care.